I enjoy going to church. I really do.
I don’t go because of the fear of divine retribution, nor do I go
because I feel like I HAVE to go. I
place myself in the “Christian” category with a subset of Protestant. This is because of my own set of circumstances. It’s a matter of my birth, my geographical
circumstances and worship preferences. I
also believe that any religious practice has merit as long as it brings no harm
and celebrates family and “loving your neighbor.” It is my belief that there are many roads
into heaven and as long as one practices the “do no harm” edict that’s just
fine. I do NOT believe that any one path
takes precedence over the other. I know
that many of you who read this disagree with that belief, but that is just the
way I see it and I am comfortable with it.
Now that I have that out of the way, let
me get to the subject at hand. Diane and
I brought up our girls in a lower valley Methodist church here in El Paso. We chose this church for the usual
reasons. First of all, we were married
in this church. Familiarity. Next, we knew people there. Socialization. The church had an excellent and active
children’s program. Parental
responsibility. The music program in
this church was probably one of the best in the city. Creative outlet. The preachers were friendly and very
caring. They visited you in the
hospital, came to your home during crisis times and served as confidantes. Nurture.
Our church life was good during our years
there. The girls grew up with great
friends and there were excellent role models in the church. Diane and I were very involved and found
ourselves at the church several days a week.
We didn’t mind and enjoyed the outlet.
The girls grew up and after they left we began to back away from being
so totally immersed. We passed the torch
and for a period of time that worked just fine.
Then it began to happen. Times began to change. One of the first things that happened was in
the late ‘70’s and early ‘80’s the “charismatic” movement started in the
church. There began a division among the
congregation as to style of worship and theology. Several families left in order to find a more
literal style of worship. As I stated
earlier I do not condemn any difference in style, but resist it when it begins
to be foisted on me. That tempest died
down after a while and the outcome wound up being the beginning of the
nondenominational churches. Again, do no
harm, love one another and I am all for it.
However, this began the death knell for many mainstream protestant
churches. The giant sucking sound we
began to hear were these churches drawing from the mainstream churches.
Here in El Paso demographics began to
heavily impact the lower valley community.
Our lower valley Methodist church began to lose membership due to
families moving out of the neighborhoods.
Children were growing up and not being replaced by young families. The protestant migration began out of the
valley and was being replaced by traditional Roman Catholic families. At that time there were two Methodist
churches in the valley. One decided to
relocate and asked our church to join them.
Diane and I favored this idea, but the old remaining families resisted
it. Now, most of these families have
passed and this once thriving church is gone.
It was absorbed as a “campus” for another Methodist church across
town. Sad.
That is the history of that one
church. Before I continue, let me put
out some facts. In 2010 a survey of
people attending church in El Paso showed this:
74.85% attended Catholic churches, 8.6 % attended nondenominational
churches, 5.7% attended Baptist churches, 2.7% attended LDS churches and 1.3%
attended Methodist churches. The
remaining attended various other denominations or are Jewish or some other
religion.
I realize that El Paso is a
unique border city and this does not reflect other cities. However, statistics do show that there is a
definite loss in membership in mainstream churches to this day. One writer even went so far as to say that
mainline churches are on the path of extinction.
After all this sound and fury we perhaps
need to step back and examine why this is happening. We can spend days discussing such things as
break down of the family, lack of parental supervision and other such
things. What I want to do is to bring it
down to a very personal level and share with you what I am observing. I am a member of a dying church. I very carefully chose this church after
Diane passed away by using my own personal rubric, what I needed. It had a friendly open feel to it and the
pastor was very engaging. The music
program was good and satisfied that personal need. I was in an atmosphere of new friends who did
not know me as (1) a poor old widower,
(2) Diane’s husband, (3) Melissa and Pam Parks’ father, or (4) retired high
school counselor. It gave me a fresh
start. Things rocked along and then I
began to notice the signs. People
started moving away. The congregation
median age became older and older. There
has been very little effort to bring in new members and, quite frankly, no
reason for anyone to want to join. The
signs are all there. The pastor was
reassigned and the new one is young and inexperienced. Money has become a huge issue. The “old timers” began to stop attending and
I could see very little visitation going on.
The choir program is struggling along and seems, at this point, to
remain the bright spot of the church.
OK, what’s the point, Ronnie? I have always espoused that in order to build
up a church it needs a great PR program.
“There’s no business like soul business!” There is an old show business adage that
states, “You gotta have a gimmick.” In
order to save souls you need butts in the pews.
If I were king of the Methodists this would be my first move in this
particular situation. In this part of
the city there are four Methodist churches within about a twelve mile
area. Each church is suffering from the
same malaise. There is a lack of
congregants and each is struggling along.
Take a lesson from the small school districts. Consolidate!
Find a central location and merge!
St. Whoever Consolidated Eastside United Methodist Church! Examine the ministerial rolls and pull in the
most powerful and charismatic pastor and assistant pastor you can find. Get a professional and scintillating music
director AND accompanist and a youth minister who will have the kids clamoring
at the door. Start a school program. Do dramatic presentations! Host concerts! Get the powerful United Methodist Women and
Men going! Have Sunday schools for any
age group and special interest. Get a
singles group going. Have grief groups,
young parent groups, college student groups….ad infinitum. Encourage our conference leaders to get with
the program, come into the 21st century and settle the LGBT issue
and reach out to that demographic.
The point is that in my little piece of
the world there are not a whole lot of Methodists around. Let’s put what’s out there together and try
to get something done. I realize that
this is a radical proposal. I also
realize that I will probably never see this happen, but it would be a nice
start. I would also propose that other
mainstream churches consider this approach.
In the meantime, back to me. I will continue to rock along for a while
where I am. I fear that there will be a
point when I have to make a decision.
I’ve got about six or seven good active years left and know that soon I
will have to make a life change.
However, it would do my heart good to see positive strides forward.
God bless us all.